PSP: Aggression and Apathy 13 Times as Common?

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

I got angry today and I shouted. I felt terrible. I have apologised, and I feel guilty about it. I don’t like behaving that way. I never have.

I am pretty sure the Ben of a few years ago would not have reacted this way. It made me want to understand how much PSP affects behaviour, both neurologically and psychologically.

I already knew PSP could affect behaviour as well as movement. What shocked me was the scale of it. I simply had no idea.

The Research That Shocked Me

A 2013 study of 154 people with clinically probable PSP examined a range of neuropsychiatric symptoms, including apathy, depression, agitation, irritability and disinhibition. The researchers found that behavioural abnormalities were common, with more than half of the participants experiencing apathy, depression and sleep problems, and approximately one-third experiencing agitation, irritability, disinhibition and eating problems.

PSP research – Gerstenecker et al., 2013

I compared those findings with a separate 2008 study of 1,590 cognitively normal older adults, which also measured neuropsychiatric symptoms, although using a different version of the assessment instrument.

Comparison research – Geda et al., 2008

The differences were extraordinary.

  • Agitation and aggression: 35.6% in PSP versus 2.8% in the comparison group, approximately 13 times as common.
  • Irritability and emotional lability: 33.1% versus 7.6%, more than four times as common.
  • Disinhibition: 31.8% versus 1.6%, an enormous difference.
  • Apathy: 61.7% versus 4.8%, approximately 13 times as common.
  • Depression: 58.4% versus 11.4%, approximately five times as common.

These figures are profound.

There is an important qualification. These were two separate studies involving different populations. The cognitively normal comparison group was older, and the researchers used different versions of the Neuropsychiatric Inventory. These are differences in reported prevalence, not scientifically established increases in individual risk. Nevertheless, I find the scale of the differences remarkable.

Disinhibition. A Word I Had Barely Considered.

Of all the findings, this one interested me most.

One way of thinking about disinhibition is as a weakening of the brain’s internal braking system.

We all have thoughts and emotions that we choose not to act upon. We get irritated, frustrated or angry, but something tells us to stop, think and consider our response. Disinhibition can make that harder.

It may show itself in different ways. You might speak without filtering and say something blunt or hurtful that you would previously have kept to yourself. You might react impulsively when angry or frustrated, act before considering the consequences, interrupt people or simply behave in ways that don’t feel consistent with the person you recognise yourself to be.

In the PSP study, almost one-third of participants experienced disinhibition. In the separate cognitively normal older group, the reported prevalence was only 1.6%.

And disinhibition is only one part of the picture. Apathy, depression, sleep disturbance, appetite changes, agitation, irritability and anxiety were all reported much more frequently in the PSP group.

Because apparently we don’t have enough physically to worry about.

Explanation or Excuse?

Does understanding that PSP may influence my behaviour make me less responsible for what I say and do?

I don’t think there is a simple answer.

PSP can affect the neurological mechanisms involved in regulating behaviour. Whether that contributed to my reaction today, I cannot know.

But understanding that possibility matters. It helps me, and hopefully the people around me, understand why the Ben of today may sometimes react differently from the Ben of a few years ago.

At the same time, I don’t want an explanation to become an excuse.

I shouted today. I apologised because, PSP or not, the person on the receiving end still experienced me shouting. PSP may be making it harder for me to control my reactions, but that doesn’t mean the consequences disappear or that I should simply shrug my shoulders and say, “It’s the PSP.”

This is a difficult contradiction to live with.

PSP is having a huge impact on me, physically and perhaps behaviourally too. Yet I still have a sense of responsibility for what I say and do, and for doing everything I reasonably can to manage it.

I cannot promise that I will always succeed. But I can recognise when I get it wrong, apologise when I need to, and keep trying.

Perhaps that is where I have landed today.

PSP may explain more of my behaviour than I realised. That doesn’t make responsibility irrelevant. It makes responsibility different.

2 Responses

  1. I think I understand your dilemma, Ben.

    My late husband, who suffered from PSP, had a few “irrational” episodes, which were hurtful at the time, but quickly forgotten.

    As if we need reminding that this condition is a censored (rhymes with witch)!!

Leave a Reply